Island School Global Politics
  • Home
  • Explorations
  • MUN
    • ISMUN Blog
  • IBDP Global Politics
    • Pre-IB Course >
      • 1. What is global politics?
      • 2. How is the course assessed?
      • 3. How can we analyse global politics?
      • 4. What political issues do I care about?
      • 5-7. Case Study: What does COVID-19 reveal about global politics?
      • 8. How can I prepare for studying global politics?
    • Unit 1: Power, Sovereignty and International Relations >
      • 1. What is the nature of power? >
        • 1. What is power?
        • 2. How does realism define power?
        • 3. How does liberalism define power?
        • 4. How do critical theories define power?
        • 5. Assessment: Which theory best explains power?
      • 2. How has state power evolved? >
        • 1. How did the nation state emerge?
        • 2. What is sovereignty?
        • 3. How is state sovereignty challenged today?
        • 4. What is the 'social contract'?
        • 5. What gives state power its legitimacy?
        • 6. Assessment: What type of states are more legitimate?
      • 3. Can other groups influence the power of the state? >
        • 1. How much power do IGOs have over states?
        • 2. Are NGOs insignificant global actors?
        • 3. How effective are social movements?
        • 4. How do resistance movements operate?
        • 5. Are political parties legitimate actors?
        • 6. Do informal forums undermine democracy?
        • 7. Assessment: How effective are other groups?
      • 4. Can global interactions improve the world? >
        • 1. Does global governance work?
        • 2. What role do treaties play?
        • 3. Does collective security work?
        • 4. Do alliances reduce or increase tensions?
        • 5. Does economic cooperation lead to interdependence?
        • 6. Is informal cooperation more effective?
        • 7. What drives modern conflicts?
        • 8. Is terrorism a reaction to globalisation?
        • 9. Can domestic conflicts influence global politics?
        • 10: Assessment: Can global interactions improve the world?
      • Unit 1: Exam Questions
    • Unit 2: Human Rights >
      • 1. How have Human Rights evolved? >
        • 1. What are human rights?
        • 2. How significant is the UDHR?
        • 3. How have human rights developed?
        • 4. Assessment: Are human rights a Western construct?
      • 2. Who or what protects our Human Rights? >
        • 1. How do states enforce human rights?
        • 2. Is international monitoring effective?
        • 3. Who enforces humanitarian law?
        • 4. How can civil society help monitor human rights?
        • 5. Assessment: Who should be responsible for human rights?
      • 3. How do Human Rights operate in practice? >
        • 1. Who makes claims on human rights?
        • 2. How are human rights contested locally?
        • 3. How are human rights contested nationally?
        • 4. How are human rights contested globally?
        • 5. Assessment: Does current human rights practice ensure equality?
      • 4. Why are Human Rights so contested? >
        • 1. Are collective rights more important?
        • 2. Are human rights universal?
        • 3. Are human rights too politicised?
        • 4. Assessment: How should we view human rights?
      • Unit 2: Exam Questions
    • Unit 3: Development >
      • 1. Why is development contested?
      • 2. How can development be helped or hindered?
      • 3. Can globalisation help increase development?
      • 4. Can development be made more sustainable?
    • Unit 4: Peace and Conflict >
      • 1. Is the use of violence ever justified? >
        • 1. What is peace, conflict and violence?
        • 2. What forms can conflict take?
        • 3. Is it right to ever go to war?
        • 4. Assessment: On what grounds can violence be justified?
      • 2. What causes conflicts to develop?
      • 3. How do conflicts evolve over time?
      • 4. Can peace be achieved by managing conflicts?
      • Unit 4: Exam Questions
    • HL Extension: Global Political Challenges >
      • Topic 1: Environment
      • Topic 2: Poverty
      • Topic 3: Health
      • Topic 4: Identity
      • Topic 5: Borders
      • Topic 6: Security
    • EA: Engagement Activity
    • EE: Extended Essay in Global Politics
    • News Blog
    • Research Links
  • More

6. Do informal forums undermine democracy?

Activity 1 - What are informal forums?


Activity Tasks
  1. Identify - Examine this image of world leaders. How many can you identify? You get ONE point for each correct name and ONE point for the country or bloc.
  2. Think/Pair/Share - What are informal forums? Discuss with a partner before sharing your ideas with the class.
  3. Define - Using the information from Slide 3 of the Lesson Presentation, write your own definition of what an informal forum is.
  4. List - With a partner, try to think of and list as many informal forums as you can. It’s harder than you think!

Activity 2 - Comparing Informal Forums


Activity Tasks
  1. Select - In groups, select one of the informal forums on this analysis sheet to research.
  2. Research - Try to record specific factual information and examples for each of the six categories: purpose/agenda; history; membership; organisation; summit achievements; criticisms and failures.
  3. Analyse - Write a paragraph answering the question, ‘What are the main similarities and differences between informal forums.’ Refer to your research analysis grids to help substantiate your answers.

Activity 3 - How effective are forums?


Activity Tasks
  1. Read - Your task is to now assess the effectiveness of the G8/G7 as an informal forum by reading and taking notes from at least two of the following sources:
    1. G8 Summit relies on hard graft, not congratulatory back patting – From the Guardian (UK)
    2. What did the G8 summit achieve? – Brookings Institute
    3. The G7 and the Future of Multilateralism
    4. Commentary: What the G7 can still offer the world
  2. Mindmap - Now draw up a mind map that explores the different sides to the proposition that ‘The G7/8 is not an effective agent of change in today’s world’. You may choose to create your mind map on paper or use mindmup.
  3. Debate - Discuss and debate the motion, ‘The G7/8 is not an effective agent of change in today’s world’. What does the majority in the class believe?

Activity 4 - Are informal forums legitimate?


Activity Tasks
  1. Identify - What do we mean when we call something democratic or undemocratic? Make a list of values that might qualify something to be considered democratic. Start with: accountability, legitimacy, transparency…
  2. Create - Create a simple two-column table to analyse the evidence for whether informal forums are undemocratic. Use the headings ‘democratic’ and ‘undemocratic’ for each column. 
  3. Organise - Now try to collect evidence for your table from the following sources:
    1. The G20 is a luxury we can't afford - The Guardian
    2. The G20, civil society, and democratic commitment
    3. Is the G20 an effective grouping?
    4. Storming the Stage - An Interview with Emily Laquer
    5. Explained: What is the G20 summit?
    6. There's Something Distinctly Undemocratic About G20 
  4. Discuss - To what extent do you think informal forums are undemocratic? ​

Further Reading


OBLIGATORY READING
  1. Heywood, A. (2011). Global Politics, pp. 117, 465, 477, 518
RECOMMENDED READING
  1. Yu, V. (2020). China will not allow G20 to discuss Hong Kong, says foreign minister. Retrieved 14 January 2020, from https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jun/24/china-will-not-allow-g20-to-discuss-hong-kong-says-foreign-minister
SUPPLEMENTARY READING
  1. Albert, E. (2020). Is BRICS Losing Its Shine for China?. Retrieved 14 January 2020, from https://thediplomat.com/2019/11/is-brics-losing-its-shine-for-china/

PREVIOUS LESSON - ARE POLITICAL PARTIES LEGITIMATE POLITICAL ACTORS?
TOPIC 4 MENU: CAN GLOBAL INTERACTIONS IMPROVE THE WORLD?

Y7-9 MYP

Y7 Humanities
Y8 Humanities
Y9 Explorations

Y10-11 IGCSE

IGCSE Global Perspectives
Global Politics & Debate
MUN

Y12-13 IBDP

Pre-IB Course
HL Extension
​EA Coursework
EE GP
News Blog
​
Research Links
  • Home
  • Explorations
  • MUN
    • ISMUN Blog
  • IBDP Global Politics
    • Pre-IB Course >
      • 1. What is global politics?
      • 2. How is the course assessed?
      • 3. How can we analyse global politics?
      • 4. What political issues do I care about?
      • 5-7. Case Study: What does COVID-19 reveal about global politics?
      • 8. How can I prepare for studying global politics?
    • Unit 1: Power, Sovereignty and International Relations >
      • 1. What is the nature of power? >
        • 1. What is power?
        • 2. How does realism define power?
        • 3. How does liberalism define power?
        • 4. How do critical theories define power?
        • 5. Assessment: Which theory best explains power?
      • 2. How has state power evolved? >
        • 1. How did the nation state emerge?
        • 2. What is sovereignty?
        • 3. How is state sovereignty challenged today?
        • 4. What is the 'social contract'?
        • 5. What gives state power its legitimacy?
        • 6. Assessment: What type of states are more legitimate?
      • 3. Can other groups influence the power of the state? >
        • 1. How much power do IGOs have over states?
        • 2. Are NGOs insignificant global actors?
        • 3. How effective are social movements?
        • 4. How do resistance movements operate?
        • 5. Are political parties legitimate actors?
        • 6. Do informal forums undermine democracy?
        • 7. Assessment: How effective are other groups?
      • 4. Can global interactions improve the world? >
        • 1. Does global governance work?
        • 2. What role do treaties play?
        • 3. Does collective security work?
        • 4. Do alliances reduce or increase tensions?
        • 5. Does economic cooperation lead to interdependence?
        • 6. Is informal cooperation more effective?
        • 7. What drives modern conflicts?
        • 8. Is terrorism a reaction to globalisation?
        • 9. Can domestic conflicts influence global politics?
        • 10: Assessment: Can global interactions improve the world?
      • Unit 1: Exam Questions
    • Unit 2: Human Rights >
      • 1. How have Human Rights evolved? >
        • 1. What are human rights?
        • 2. How significant is the UDHR?
        • 3. How have human rights developed?
        • 4. Assessment: Are human rights a Western construct?
      • 2. Who or what protects our Human Rights? >
        • 1. How do states enforce human rights?
        • 2. Is international monitoring effective?
        • 3. Who enforces humanitarian law?
        • 4. How can civil society help monitor human rights?
        • 5. Assessment: Who should be responsible for human rights?
      • 3. How do Human Rights operate in practice? >
        • 1. Who makes claims on human rights?
        • 2. How are human rights contested locally?
        • 3. How are human rights contested nationally?
        • 4. How are human rights contested globally?
        • 5. Assessment: Does current human rights practice ensure equality?
      • 4. Why are Human Rights so contested? >
        • 1. Are collective rights more important?
        • 2. Are human rights universal?
        • 3. Are human rights too politicised?
        • 4. Assessment: How should we view human rights?
      • Unit 2: Exam Questions
    • Unit 3: Development >
      • 1. Why is development contested?
      • 2. How can development be helped or hindered?
      • 3. Can globalisation help increase development?
      • 4. Can development be made more sustainable?
    • Unit 4: Peace and Conflict >
      • 1. Is the use of violence ever justified? >
        • 1. What is peace, conflict and violence?
        • 2. What forms can conflict take?
        • 3. Is it right to ever go to war?
        • 4. Assessment: On what grounds can violence be justified?
      • 2. What causes conflicts to develop?
      • 3. How do conflicts evolve over time?
      • 4. Can peace be achieved by managing conflicts?
      • Unit 4: Exam Questions
    • HL Extension: Global Political Challenges >
      • Topic 1: Environment
      • Topic 2: Poverty
      • Topic 3: Health
      • Topic 4: Identity
      • Topic 5: Borders
      • Topic 6: Security
    • EA: Engagement Activity
    • EE: Extended Essay in Global Politics
    • News Blog
    • Research Links
  • More